These shoes have a scuff on the side of the left heel. There is still wear left in the soles. Please see photos. Keywords: Johnston & Murphy, Mens Shoes, Black Leather, Wingtip Oxfords, Dress Shoes, Size 11.5, Medium Width, Formal Shoes, Business Casual, Leather Shoes, Lace Up Shoes, Mens Footwear, Fashion Shoes, Classic Style Thanks for checking out this item. We strive to give the best photos possible, please check them for accurate sizing and condition information. Please feel free to contact us for any additional details or to ask any questions you might have. All our clothes are clean and ready to wear. Be aware that colors may appear different on different devices. Again...thanks!
